Planet of the Humans reveals that green technology isn’t going to save our power-hungry lifestyle. We can’t rely on technological fixes to address the climate crisis without dealing with economic and population growth.
Condemnation from Green Energy advocates is plentiful, and I’ll mostly leave analysis of energy conversion methods to people with that expertise. I find the torrent of humorously irrational reactions to hearing the truth about our excessive presence far more entertaining.
In chronological order, far more than you’ll want to read:
The day before its Earth Day release, Michael Shellenberger noted, “Like many environmental documentaries, ‘Planet of Humans’ endorses debunked Malthusian ideas that the world is running out of energy.”
Since energy can neither be created nor destroyed, running out is easily debunked. It’s a bit harder to debunk the fact that trying to convert enough energy for our growing demands is causing massive ecological destruction and is most likely impossible with existing technology.
The Guardian’s Peter Bradshaw gives it four out of five stars. Planet of the Humans review—contrarian eco-doc April 22nd.
“This, says Gibbs, is the queasy merger of environmentalism and capitalism – and he makes a refreshingly sceptical case. But he takes it further, suggesting that unfettered capitalism and its insanity of eternal growth on a finite planet is also what is leading us to the cliff edge. True enough, although his comments on overpopulation have an unintentionally ironic chime, in the middle of the Covid-19 outbreak.”
As tragic as this pandemic is, our 225,000 per day increase more than makes up for our losses, as of late October, in less than six days.
“Most chillingly of all, Gibbs at one stage of the film appears to suggest that there is no cure for any of this, that, just as humans are mortal, so the species itself is staring its own mortality in the face. But he appears to back away from that view by the end, saying merely that things need to change. But what things and how?”
Fair question. The fact that we’re into overshoot and can’t grow on like this wasn’t followed up with anything like, ‘And so we need economic system change and better choices in the size of our families.’
“It’s left up the the viewers’ imagination and, disappointingly, many imagine racism, classism, misogyny, genocidal population control, and mass murder.”
Well, Peter Bradshaw imagines that anyway. It’s discouraging they don’t instead imagine voluntary family planning and free reproductive health services for all.
Films for Action, one of the distributers, who briefly pulled it but decided a dialog would be better, wrote on April 23rd:
Skepticism Is Healthy, but Planet of the Humans Is Toxic - A Critical Review.
“At the heart of Planet of the Humans is the basic premise that humans cannot continue a path of infinite ‘growth’ on a finite planet. That much is indisputable.”
Infinite ‘growth’ isn’t possible—not sure about real growth.
“But what does it mean? Does it mean that all industrialization is bad? Does it mean that replacing fossil fuels with an all-electric economy fueled by wind and sun is not achievable or not desirable?”
Do straw man questions count as biofuel?
“Does it mean that there is no solution to global warming, apart from killing off a large part of the world’s population?”
If only there were a way to reduce population size without killing anyone… Hmmm.
Brian Kahn on April 23rd opines, [POTH] Comes This Close to Actually Getting the Real Problem, Then Goes Full Ecofascism.
“Gibbs uses this situation to take the leap to population control as the only solution.”
The real leap is from Gibbs saying there are too many of us to Kahn crying population control. But it gets better.
“Yes, renewables are bad and so are billionaires and the corporate-philanthropic industrial complex so, Gibbs concludes, we should probably get rid of some humans ASAP.”
A greater leap from population control to mass murder.
“Over the course of the movie, he interviews a cast of mostly white experts who are mostly men to make that case. It’s got a bit more than a whiff of eugenics and ecofascism, which is a completely bonkers takeaway from everything presented.”
For sure, that’s a completely bonkers takeaway from everything presented.
“If renewables are so bad, then what does a few million less people on the planet going to do? Oh, and who are we going to knock off or control for? Who decides? How does population control even solve the problem of corporate influence on nonprofits and politics? Those questions lead to a dark place.”
Maybe that’s where they come from.
[POTH] Skewers Renewables, Delivers Anti-Human Malthusianism
Robert Bryce, April 23rd:
“Humans are like cockroaches. We need fewer of them. That’s the fundamental message... It offers no clues as to how we humans, all 7.8 billion of us, should be meeting our needs for energy, food, and shelter.
The film... concludes with this bit of Malthusianism: ‘We humans must accept that infinite growth on a finite planet is suicide,’ Gibbs says in his dirge-like monotone. ‘We must accept that our human presence is already far beyond sustainability and all that that implies.’
That line would have been right at home in Paul Ehrlich’s 1968 book, The Population Bomb,
Gibbs reveals himself to be little more than another doomsayer. And he does so despite the fact that more people are living longer, healthier, freer lives than at any time in human history. What we need now, particularly in the middle of this deadly pandemic, aren’t more prophets of doom and despair. Instead, we need an environmental ethic that is pro-human, pro-wildlife, pro-land-sparing, and yes, pro-energy and pro-nuclear.”
No clue as to why we need more nuclear energy, food, and shelter.
Ketan Joshi, on April 24, objects, “Nothing in this is new.” Dismissing an idea because it’s “nothing new” is nothing new. “Old” shows up 20 times in
Planet of the humans: A reheated mess of lazy, old myths Joshi points out specific faults, but what really upsets him is saying there are too many of us and implying we need to do something about it.
“...[Gibbs] ends up at population control—a cruel, evil and racist ideology that you can see coming right from the start of the film.”
“Population control,” whatever horror he imagines it to be, was never suggested.
“There is no information provided on which people in the world need to stop fucking, but we can take a guess, based on the demographics of the people doing the asking.”
Joshi seems unaware of the most effective green technology for climate mitigation: contraception. Something hundreds of millions of couples want and are denied worldwide.
What Planet of the Humans gets wrong April 24.
“At the end of the movie, Gibbs doesn’t exactly say that the solution is population control, but strongly implies it: ‘It’s not one thing, but everything we humans are doing. A human-caused apocalypse. If we get ourselves under control, all things are possible.’
“This also happens to be the major plot point of Avengers Infinity War… His Thanos-approved solution to environmental catastrophe takes things to a level he wouldn’t need to if he actually read some climate research…”
Somehow, getting ourselves under control equates to wiping out half of humanity. Really, the alternative to half of humanity dying off is voluntarily ceasing our redundant procreation.
Humankind is challenged, as it has never been challenged before to prove its maturity and its mastery—not of nature but of itself.
~Rachel Carson 1962
Bill McKibben thoroughly responds to the documentary on April 25th in Rolling Stone, with many links to many articles debunking its claims. He skirted the issue of human population pressures, maybe because he agrees, privately at least.
On April 28th, Eoin Higgins writes, “Jeff Gibbs plays fast and loose with the facts, attacks the wrong targets, and even ends up arguing for ecofascist solutions to the climate crisis.”
I don’t think that word means what you think it means.
“In a more disturbing move, Gibbs promotes population control as the best answer to the warming of the planet.”
Rather, the message is that our economic and population growth must be addressed.
Higgins quotes Film for Action, “It’s true we can’t keep growing forever, in the same way we can’t keep consuming the Earth forever...”
Exactly. We are into overshoot due to both population and consumption.
“... but in high-consumption countries, populations are already declining, and in areas where populations are still growing, the ‘impact on Earth’ is still low compared to the impact of ‘rich’ nations,” the group wrote.”
Populations in high-consuming countries are not declining, though that’s where a lower birth rate would reduce CO2-e emissions the most. Where population growth is highest, gender equality and standards of living are lowest. Emissions are also lowest, but ecological impact from growth devastates biodiversity.
“The truth is, pinning our problems on population lets industrial capitalism off the hook.”
Ignoring the population component of capitalism keeps workers on the hook. Capitalism feeds on our increasing numbers. We should let it starve.
Michael Moore and filmmakers respond to criticism on his podcast Rumble April 28th.
On 28 April, Robin Maynard of Population Matters suggests an alternative ending for the documentary, with practical ideas that aren’t as common as they should be, including “women’s empowerment, education, and universal access to contraception and the choice to use it.”
Leah C. Stokes on April 28 calls it a gift to Big Oil. “Planet of the Humans deceives viewers about clean energy and climate activists.”
But what’s really bad is, yeah once again, mention of population.
“Yet, the film Moore backed concludes that population control, not clean energy, is the answer. This is a highly questionable solution, which has more in common with anti-immigration hate groups than the progressive movement.”
Quite the choice: clean energy or hate groups. Neither clean nor dirty energy will keep up with population growth. Providing everyone with their fair share of energy might be possible if there were fewer of us.
“The fact is that wealthy people in the developed world have the largest environmental footprints—and they also have the lowest birthrates.”
So, we’re a problem but not a big problem.
“When this message is promoted, it’s implying that poor, people of color should have fewer children.”
High birth rates in over-exploited regions often come to mind when population pressures come up. After all, our birth rates are the lowest and thus don’t need self-examination. On the other hand, since the Eco-footprint of each new person we wealthy create will be the largest, perhaps we could reconsider our own procreative choices.
“Not to mention the fact that pushing population control is completely disrespectful of women’s reproductive autonomy.”
Disrespect for women’s reproductive autonomy is arguably the primary reason there are too many of us today. “Population control” is what we already have: coerced conceptions and mandatory motherhood is a global injustice.
“It is sad to think of the world we are leaving for children. Yet, if we embraced clean energy, then they would not have to grow up in a world tied to dirty fossil fuels.”
True, today’s children would live in a less sad future if burning fossil fuels were greatly reduced. Their lifetimes would also be more abundant if we weren’t adding a few billion more siblings. Half of our human family is already barely scraping out a living.
Josh Fox, director of Gasland, writes on April 30th, “Then comes its most immoral and damning gambit: the claim that reducing the population is among the only effective remedies. We see old white male after old white male declaring there is no solution to climate change except reducing the population. (With this many white guys we can only guess which groups of people are supposed to stop reproducing.) To claim that it is all those overpopulated countries that are causing the problem would be deeply problematic even in ‘normal’ times.”
It would be if they made that claim. They didn’t. He seems to imply we’re not an overpopulated country.
“But to do so in the middle of a global pandemic that is killing a disproportionate number of black and brown people is more than just racist. It can be seen as an incitement to eco-fascist population controls.”
Let this be a warning to anyone who dares to point out that there are more of us than Earth can provide for: you’ll be called an immoral, racist, eco-fascist who wants to control poor people’s reproductive lives.
Video interview of Josh fox on The Hill Rising. May 1st. A host called out his incorrect population claims.
Kristine Mattis on May 2nd presents a balanced view of what we can learn about the marketing of ideas, and a rational approach to human population pressures.
“The term ‘eco-fascism’ has been bandied around by critics regarding the mere mention of the issue. This hyperbole is a straw-man. Critical and thoughtful adults should be able to discuss human population without the use of such invectives. From what I saw, the film made no implications as to the whos, whats, whys, or hows of the topic. It simply mentioned that human population has exploded, which it has.”
Dangerous Solutions to the Climate Crisis On May 2nd, Jesse Harris notes, “Population control has deep roots in the vile history of environmental racism. POTH suggests that population control should play a bigger role in climate discourse.”
They don’t suggest this.
“The core of the ‘overpopulation’ argument is quite simple and logical—which is what makes it attractive. POTH offers a concise summary: there are too many human beings using too much too fast. This statement, at its core, is true.
In order for population control to be a meaningful part of a solution to climate change, you would need to take some drastic steps. A lot of people would need to be sterilized or killed. So, the question is, who would it be?
While ‘population control’ does not make an explicit reference to race, we all know that black and brown populations are the ones doing the growing, meaning they are the ones that would need to be controlled.”
Too bad we don’t all know that white populations are also growing. No one needs to be controlled: we all need more freedom, particularly the freedom to not procreate.
“The most maddening aspect of POTH’s overpopulation speculation is how little the concepts are fleshed out. The film declares that ‘we’ve got to deal with population growth,’ that ‘We humans are poised for a fall from an unimaginable height’ as a result of overpopulation, and that ‘every expert they talked to’ wanted to discuss the issue. No time is spent explaining how a population control policy might work, who would implement such a policy, or project how much it would decrease CO2 emissions.”
Why eco-leftists are suddenly turning on Michael Moore
On May 2nd, Steven W. Mosher cleverly notes: “I don’t know about you, but any time anyone tells me we need to reduce the world’s population my answer is always the same: ‘You first’.
Jeff Gibbs’ documentary... presents evidence that it’s not as green as it’s promoted to be, and contends that we can’t rely of technological fixes alone to address the climate crisis. We have to deal with economic and population growth as well, perhaps more so.
The May 5th episode of “Let’s Just Have a Think” clearly takes us through the inaccuracies about energy, but lacks depth of understanding about human population.
3 times [POTH] gets the facts wrong (and 3 times it gets them right)
Science professor Ian Lowe on May 6th:[POTH] rightly argues that infinite growth on a finite planet is “suicide”. But the film’s bogus claims threaten to overshadow that message.
What does the film get right? ... several entirely valid points:
The film observes that population growth is the elephant in the room when it comes to climate change. It says politicians are reluctant to talk about limits to population growth “because that would be bad for business”.
As one observer in the film says, the people in charge aren’t nervous enough. I agree.
An increasing population means increasing demand for energy and other resources, accelerating climate change.
May 6th, in [POTH] Review: Shining a Light on the Energy Black Box Megan Seibert writes:
“Kudos to the filmmakers for covering overpopulation, the most taboo yet important of the degrowth variables. Unsurprisingly, this has been the most attacked aspect of the movie’s degrowth message, with the familiar fear mongering outcries of ecofascism. The movie’s nod to curbing consumption has been more positively received, which is also unsurprising since it’s the most socially palatable aspect of degrowth.”
It’s also the least likely to happen. Anyone want less than they have now?
George Monbiot weighs in May 7:
“The film offers only one concrete solution to our predicament: the most toxic of all possible answers. ‘We really have got to start dealing with the issue of population … without seeing some sort of major die-off in population, there’s no turning back.’
“Yes, population growth does contribute to the pressures on the natural world. But while the global population is rising by 1% a year, consumption, until the pandemic, was rising at a steady 3%.”
This shows how effects of overpopulation are amplified.
“High consumption is concentrated in countries where population growth is low. Where population growth is highest, consumption tends to be extremely low. Almost all the growth in numbers is in poor countries largely inhabited by black and brown people.
When wealthy people, such as Moore and Gibbs, point to this issue without the necessary caveats, they are saying, in effect, ’it’s not Us consuming, it’s Them breeding.’ It’s not hard to see why the far right loves this film.”
The far right, Breitbart anyway, doesn’t love it:
“Though I can’t say I share many of Michael Moore’s and Jeff Gibbs’s political assumptions — certainly not the Malthusian belief underpinning the movie that overpopulation is killing our planet.”
Y’all need to have an agreeable chat with George.
George Monbiot continues on Twitter May 7th:
“Prompted by the shocking falsehoods in Planet of the Humans, this thread asks why so many people in rich nations claim that the biggest environmental problem is #PopulationGrowth. The conclusion will enrage some people, but I think it’s unavoidable.
...Global population growth today is 1.05%. That’s half the peak growth rate, reached in 1963 (2.2%). In other words, population growth is not, as many claim, exponential. The rate is falling rapidly.”
Since the rate of growth is falling, growth can’t be a problem. In reality, there are already way too many of us, even if we weren’t growing.
“As Our World in Data notes, ’Even several billion additional people in low-income countries … would leave global emissions almost unchanged. 3 or 4 billion low income individuals would only account for a few percent of global CO2.’”
Their misery and wildlife habitat loss will be compounded, but not their emissions, so no big deal.
“But I see population growth repeatedly blamed as THE MAIN CAUSE of climate breakdown and other global issues. This is flat wrong.
A borderline straw man: overpopulation is one of the main causes of the climate crisis, plus many other problems, which are ignored because of environmentalists’ obsession with CO2 emissions.
“Affluent people with enormous impacts pointing the finger at poor people with tiny impacts.”
No population-awareness organization does this. Only ignorant individuals sometimes do.
“Nor am I claiming that most of those who over-emphasise population are intentional racists. I think it is possible to entertain subconscious racist beliefs without actively wishing to discriminate against people of colour. But I also believe we should call it out for what it is.”
He calls it racism elsewhere. Population-shaming may be the most effective tool today for shutting down conversations about our excessive presence.
On YouTube, Zac & Jesse “In Depth” Planet of the Humans: DEBUNKED May 8th
Starting at 41:30
“The one thing that he seems to be saying is there needs to be less humans. OK, you can say that, but he doesn’t say how you can accomplish that goal which means that I have to guess how we could have less humans. So number one could be limit the number of children being born per family... so we can have a global one-child policy... sure that would be great, but I’d like to point out, when you’re born as a little baby you’re not using the most resources. It’s when you’re older, so this would have about a 20 year effect, which is too late...”
A new human begins causing more CO2 emissions before they’re even born. At least two gender reveal parties have ignited massive wildfires.
“So the only other option if you wanna get rid of people is you either ship them off the planet, which we don’t have the means to do in any great numbers, or you just have to kill people. So, is he just suggesting that we go around murdering people to address climate change? Because those are the only options that we have.”
Climate Denier Roundup, joined in on May 12th with:
“By falsely framing the climate problem as one of too many people, [POTH] plays into the racist rhetorical framework of eco-facism, shifting the blame from the rich, largely white countries responsible for most of the CO2 in the atmosphere and instead leading the audience to believe that it’s overcrowded, brown, foreign nations who need to change.”
Funny how this accusation is never followed with an admonishment for us to change our own procreative habits.
In an interview on May 13th, Leah Stokes goes further: “When it comes to population control that’s a very racist thing to promote.”
The term ‘population control’ is no longer used by serious sustainable population groups. Today, it’s mostly used by people opposed to awareness of human population pressures.
“In the US, groups that advocate that are classified as hate groups because they’re also often anti-immigration.”
The Southern Poverty Law Center has designated the Federation for American Immigration Reform a hate group due to their racist rhetoric in opposition to immigration. No population awareness group has that distinction.
“White people, who are wealthier on average, are already having fewer children...”
But not fewer enough. We’re the ones with the largest footprint, and we’re still growing.
“...and it’s people in the developing world, who are usually people of colour, who are having more children...”
Sure, shift the blame to over-exploited people in poor countries while we live unsustainably.
“...partly because they haven’t developed, they haven’t the same industrialisation and yet the film is saying that industrialisation is evil, right, any kind of progress is evil, and also population control is the answer. So that makes absolutely no sense.”
Development and industrialization don’t guarantee lower birth rates, but do raise environmental impact.
Empowerment or ‘kicking down’. The truth about population concern.
On 14 May, Population Matters Director Robin Maynard responds to environmental writer George Monbiot’s denigration of population campaigners in a recent Guardian piece:
“He succumbed to his own toxic swamp of denial and indiscriminate denigration when he directed his anger against anyone who dares to raise the subject of human population as being a factor in our global ecological crisis. In doing so, he gave oxygen to those same dark forces and false prophets of infinite growth on a finite planet.
It wasn’t climate deniers who raised the factor of human population, which so provoked Monbiot’s ire... ‘...every expert I talked to wanted to bring my attention to the same underlying problem: there are too many human beings, using too much, too fast.’[Gibbs]
Monbiot conflates concern about population with concern about population growth. Our efforts, and the attentions of the vast majority of people concerned about population, are most certainly not just about or focused on ‘black and brown people’ whose per capita consumption and global impact is low. Population Matters’ work promoting smaller families is focussed on the number and behaviour of high consuming, high-emitting people in the Global North because of their disproportionate impact on the global environment. Our messaging that overconsumption, global injustice and systemic inequity must be addressed is explicit and consistent.
George Monbiot somewhat grudgingly admits that population contributes to environmental degradation, but then goes straight on to savage the motivations, integrity and intelligence of those who campaign for positive, equitable and empowering solutions. In this he does the causes of environmental protection and global justice a great disservice.”
No Escape from Planet of the Humans’ Inconvenient Truths
Podcast from World Population Balance May 25th.
“Some have accused the filmmakers of racism simply because the film raises the issue of overpopulation. This interview sound bite from respected Post Carbon Institute fellow Richard Heinberg is typical of the film’s messaging about overshoot and overpopulation:
‘There are too many human beings, using too much, too fast.’”
Responding to critics, Moore, Gibbs, and Zehner talk about consumption and economic growth, but shy away from addressing human population pressures, other than to denounce population control. Is the issue too controversial even for them? Population-shaming is a powerful social influence.
On June 3rd, Dave Gardner provides another analysis of reactions to mentioning human population pressures, including a transcript of the section which seems to offend so many.
World Population Balance hosted a webinar on YouTube and a follow-up discussion of POTH, offered as a podcast with plenty of links for follow-up.
On June 24th, Dana Nuccitelli notes, “...curbing growth can slow climate change, but only clean technologies can stop it.”
That fallacy was the movie’s main point: it can’t.
“In fact, global population growth has steadily declined from 2% per year in the late-1960s to just over 1% per year today. And most of the growth is happening in developing countries where citizens have small carbon footprints.”
I wrote about this common dismissal of human population pressures in 2011 when we hit seven billion.
Mark Z. Jacobson’s 100% Clean, Renewable Energy and Storage for Everything was released in August 2020. In “Obstacles to Overcome,” conflicts and poverty are listed, but not our ever-increasing human population. Pointing out inaccuracies in this book is likely to get you sued.
Max Blumenthal on September 7th wrote: The Michael Moore-produced ‘Planet of the Humans’ faced a coordinated suppression campaign led by professional climate activists backed by the same ‘green’ billionaires, Wall Street investors, industry insiders and family foundations skewered in the film. Jeff Gibbs notes, “We must take control of our environmental movement and our future from billionaires and their permanent war on Planet Earth. They are not our friends.”
On Rumble, Michael Moore hosted Max Blumenthal to talk about The Plot To Kill “Planet of the Humans”. Population didn’t come up. October 13, 2020.
Fifty years ago, human population pressures were an integral part of environmental awareness. In January 2020, Extinction Rebellion UK tweeted:
We stand against racism and nationalism in the climate movement, including challenging our own privilege and biases. We reject racist dog-whistles blaming the crisis on population levels, and we welcome climate refugees. We can only survive by honouring our common humanity.
This was met with strong disagreement on Twitter, so awareness persists, but comments in the above articles show how pervasive this attitude is among reporters.
Jeff Gibbs downplays human population pressures. On Rumble #140 November 17th, at 22 minutes he notes, “It’s not how many people the planet can sustain, it’s how many people can the planet endure,” adding defensively that Bill McKibben “wrote a book on population Maybe One, and Al Gore had population in his film.”
At 43 minutes: “...people that are well taken care of and have access to family planning and birth control tend to have fewer kids and tend to be able to think about taking care of the environment. People that are desperate and struggling cannot think about taking care of the environment.”
At 58 minutes: “There are so many exciting things on a smaller scale, though I just want to be clear, the big picture is really important, but man, just supporting planned parenthood, y’know, advocating for education for women and for birth control world wide, we just forgot all about that.” After those little things, he jumps to converting lawns to wildlife habitat.
Finally, at the 1:03 mark: “… growing human presence, especially it’s been two things, it’s population growth and growth of consumption, but the thing we’re all addicted to right now in this economy is the growth of consumption, of capitalism, and industrialism.”
Gibbs’ statements aren’t controversial. He may not have been influenced by population-shaming, but others seeing what happens to anyone who dares to suggest that there are too many of us, including David Attenborough, might think twice before doing so.